Resolving Past Safeguarding Issues: Our Settlement with the Central Bank of Ireland
TLDR: Coinbase Ireland Limited (CBIE) has cooperated with the Central Bank of Ireland (CBI) to reach a settlement over its historic safeguarding practices, including the outsourcing of certain safeguarding operations. We have fully addressed the concerns that led to this settlement and there was no customer impact: no client suffered any financial loss or was unable to access their funds as a result of these historic practices. Under the settlement, CBIE will pay a €3.25 million fine.

Today's Announcement
Today, the CBI announced a settlement with CBIE, our Irish electronic money (e-money) institution, which provides fiat services to European customers. This settlement resolves an investigation into how CBIE calculated and held funds in its safeguarding accounts. CBIE self-reported many of the items described in the settlement to the CBI in January 2024 and has since fully fixed them.
Safeguarding is a core responsibility of our business. While these issues did not result in any customer losses or limit customer access to funds, we have since strengthened our safeguarding processes, added further technical controls, and brought in additional expertise to ensure our regulatory obligations are met.
Coinbase’s Safeguarding Programme
As a licensed e-money institution, CBIE must hold customer funds in designated safeguarding accounts, separate from funds held for Coinbase customers in other jurisdictions or Coinbase corporate funds.
The CBI's investigation focused on historical concerns with CBIE’s safeguarding processes, including technical data discrepancies that affected our safeguarding calculation, the use of non-CBIE bank accounts to receive customer deposits before transferring those funds to CBIE’s safeguarding accounts, and how certain safeguarding processes were outsourced. These historical issues fell into five areas, all of which have been fully resolved:
Deposit arrangements during the 2023 U.S. banking crisis. Before the banking crisis, CBIE customers made US dollar deposits into CBIE’s account at Silvergate Bank. When Silvergate was at risk of failure, CBIE directed 30 customers to deposit into a Coinbase, Inc. FBO account at another US bank to maintain access to banking services and protect customers’ deposits from bank failure. This meant CBIE customer funds were held alongside funds belonging to customers of another Coinbase entity, contrary to safeguarding requirements. Although our daily Treasury Rebalancing Process moved those funds into a CBIE safeguarding account on a daily basis, it did not prevent the initial mixing of funds.
Deposits following the post-Brexit migration. When Brexit required us to migrate EEA customers previously served by Coinbase’s UK affiliate to CBIE, we provided those customers with new bank account details and instructed them to use CBIE’s account for future deposits. Instead of sending to this new account, some of those customers continued to use the previous UK deposit accounts. Coinbase later introduced system-level blocks to reject further misdirected deposits. Although our daily Treasury Rebalancing Process moved those funds into a CBIE safeguarding account on a daily basis, it did not prevent the initial mixing of funds with UK customer deposits.
Withdrawals by non-CBIE customers. For liquidity reasons, some Euro withdrawals from US- or UK-based customers of other Coinbase entities were paid from CBIE’s safeguarding account. Although our Treasury Rebalancing Process moved funds back into CBIE’s safeguarding account each day to fully cover the amount it needed to hold for its customers, this practice was not in line with regulatory requirements.
Technical errors in daily safeguarding calculations. CBIE used a technical dashboard to calculate how much it needed to hold in safeguarding accounts each day. Due to inadvertent coding errors in that dashboard, CBIE’s safeguarding account was underfunded on average by approximately 0.54% of CBIE’s total safeguarding obligation in 2023 and H1 of 2024. This error was fixed within days of its discovery in 2024, and CBIE has since enhanced its technical controls.
Keeping CBI informed of changes to our safeguarding practices. CBIE’s safeguarding practices evolved after it applied for its EMI licence, but it did not notify CBI of all changes. We have since strengthened our reporting processes to ensure changes to these practices are promptly communicated to CBI.
Coinbase's Commitment to Compliance
No customer suffered any financial loss as a result of these matters, and no customer was ever unable to access their funds. CBIE takes its safeguarding responsibilities seriously and has agreed to this settlement. Over the past five years, CBIE has made a series of improvements to outsourcing and safeguarding practices. CBIE self-identified several of these issues and reported them to the CBI in January 2024. The vast majority of the underlying controls issues were addressed that same year. We have now fully resolved these historical issues by strengthening our technical safeguarding controls and redesigning how we calculate our safeguarding obligations to make data errors easier to detect.
Since January 2025, CBIE’s new safeguarding process has been examined in two different third-party validations, with no remaining issues identified. CBIE has also introduced a €25 million guaranty bond as an additional safeguarding mechanism, and appointed a dedicated Head of Safeguarding before the CBI introduced the equivalent role across the industry earlier this year.
Coinbase has since moved its European headquarters to Luxembourg. All EEA Coinbase customers will continue to receive services without interruption.
CBIE recognises the importance of safeguarding, and we are committed to maintaining strong safeguarding controls and preventing similar technical issues from recurring. We appreciate the CBI's engagement throughout this process and remain committed to working constructively with regulators in every jurisdiction in which we operate.





